(Talk of the Town photos by Jennifer Zartman Romano) Above, representing many demographics, local residents listen intently as fellow community members share their perspectives on the high school building project. Below, at left, Barry Dupen , a local resident, parent and engineering professor at IPFW, says he's in favor of the building project for the sake of his child who will attend the high school in a few years. Below, at right, CCHS student Jamie Hiss outlines the reasons she feels a new high school is necessary. At bottom, the WCCS school board studies the tax implications of building a new school.
By Jennifer Zartman Romano
With a unanimous vote of the Whitley County Consolidated School’s board of directors Tuesday evening, the process toward building a new Columbia City High School building on the grounds of the existing Indian Springs Middle School and Little Turtle Elementary School complex moved a step forward.
The board members in attendance, in addition to the absent members Bob Thomas, Don Armstrong and William Tucker, who voted verbally or in writing, approved the motion to adopt the 1028 resolution and the preliminary determination resolution put forth during the meeting.
Prior to the vote of the board, representatives from the architectural firm Gibraltar and the financial firm Cities Security Corporation spoke on the scope and financial implications of the project, respectively. Board vice president Tim Bloom began the meeting and school superintendent Laura Huffman spoke of the journey the board and school system has taken to get to the point of choosing to build a new high school. 
Bloom shared that the discovery process began three years ago. Since that time, there have been studies and the development of a task force to determine the school’s needs and the need for a new building. In the end, the board felt it was important to move forward.
“Education is about working for the potential of our youth,” said Huffman. “I find education fascinating…This is quite a journey.”
“Tonight is one step in that process,” Huffman said, sharing ways staff and students offered input into building needs and wants.
“We’ve had the opportunity to talk to a lot of community groups and they’ve had some excellent suggestions as well,” Huffman continued.
Space topped the list as Huffman’s most noted concern with the exiting space, a problem she feels would be alleviated by a bigger, more functional building elsewhere. That building, they say, would be able to accommodate technological and learning needs that could not be addressed in the current building or at the current site.
“I see great learning, but it is hindered by a lack of space,” Huffman said.
Jim Thompson of Gibralter Design discussed the analysis and summary conclusions as well as project parameters, additionally echoing Huffman’s statements about a lack of space in the existing school. “Many of the teachers are challenged because they don’t have enough space…there’s 60,000 square foot missing,” Thompson said, comparing the school’s relative size to other similarly-populated high schools in the state.
Thompson estimated that it would cost $54,787,690 to renovate the existing Columbia City High School building and that the project would take several years to complete, during which time students would be going to school amid constant construction.
He also spoke of the ease in building a new school on the available 80 acres owned by the school at the Indian Springs Middle School site with the future availability of another 30 acres, parking for 800 cars and 20 buses. In all, Gibralter’s preliminary cost estimate to build a new school in the new location would be $48,774,000 and could be completed by December 2011. 
Rod Wilson, a representative of Cities Security Corporation., broke the costs down before sharing the final price tag of the school: $59,600,000.
The total construction would be $48,774,000 plus equipment and technology at $4,878,000 plus $1,450,000 for changes during the building process plus other costs of $4,498,000. The “other” costs would include demolition of the existing high school building on Whitley Street, overhead, supervision, professional fees, underwriting, legal costs, interest, etc.
Wilson said, “What we’re talking about is a maximum 25 year payment.”
He estimated the financial impact on taxpayers at 27 cents and a total 60 cents debt tax rate. In addition to discussing the potential operational costs not included in the price estimates, and the possible need for more staffing, also not included, Wilson used charts to demonstrate the dollar value of building now versus building later.
“If you wait a year to do this, there will be a cost of inflation,” he said. He said there would be costs associate with upkeep on the existing building until a new one could be constructed.
Initially, before the final vote of the school board was taken, members of the community had the opportunity to speak. “We want everyone to have their peace,” said board vice president Bloom.
The majority of those who addressed the board, spoke favorably for the project.
“We owe it to the youth…our kids…to give them the best environment we can,” one long-time educator said. “This community has treasured the youth and I hope that continues,” she said.
“I came in a skeptic, but I can tell you in all truthfulness this is a well thought-out project,” said September McConnell, a local resident and parent of a high school student. McConnell expounded on the dangers of the community settling for “good enough.”
In opposition, Steve Heaston asked the board to consider the current economic state, price of fuel and tax burden on the people of Whitley County.
“Where’s it gonna end? How are people going to afford it,” he asked. “I question the common sense, wisdom and good judgment on the timing of building a new school.”
Brian Lewis, CCHS football coach and teacher, said, “By the time they get here (the students) have been in great facilities,” but described the exiting school as “a let down.”
“Nobody’s asking for a Taj Mahal,” Lewis said. “I think we’ve handicapped our kids to a degree.”
Former CCHS teacher Micah Thomas said that he felt the existing school building had exceeded its usefulness and it was time to move on. “We’ve gotten our money’s worth. We’ve made do. We’ve cobbled…we’ve cobbled enough. It’s time.”
Addressing the board, Columbia City Police Chief Michael Petersen asked, “What else can we invest in besides our children?”
In all, more than 25 members of the community shared their opinion, point of view, their approval or their concern for the project – representing local leaders, taxpayers, every age range and many occupations.
The final vote was cast by the school board at nearly 10 p.m.
